Residential tree removal limit climbs in Lacey

Posted

The Lacey City Council voted unanimously to raise the number of trees homeowners may remove from their properties.

The move permits five tree removals within a five-year period, which up from three. 

The council also strengthened the ability of the city to pursue property owners who cut trees without authorization. 

The council approved the changes via Ordinance 1707 at a meeting on Tuesday, Nov. 17. Council members adopted the measure even though the Lacey Planning Commission had recommended rejecting the changes. 

The vote partially reverses restrictions the council adopted in 2022. The council voted 4-2 that year to lower the residential limit from five trees in three years to three trees in five years. A Lacey Tree Task Force recommended a five-tree limit at the time. 

Complaints about the three-tree cap continued at city council and planning commission meetings in the years that followed. Code enforcement staff also reported unpermitted tree removals they had few ways to resolve. The council responded by adding tree standards to its 2026 planning work program, and ordering a targeted review. 

Five-tree allowance 

The revised limit takes effect five days after the ordinance was published on Thursday, Nov. 19. 

Trees may be removed for landscaping, gardening, solar access, or general property and utility work. Homeowners must first obtain a land clearing permit exemption from the city. The change does not apply to historical trees or trees in environmentally sensitive areas. 

Council member Carolyn Cox asked whether homeowners could use the exemption repeatedly over successive five-year periods until no trees remained. 

Lacey Senior Planner Hans Shepherd said a separate municipal requirement determines the minimum number of trees based on lot square footage. 

“So the five trees within a five-year period would not impact that minimum requirement for how many trees you’re required to have on a lot,” Shepherd said.

“So through this program or process that we’re looking at tonight, you would still be required to maintain that threshold, and you wouldn’t over time be able to go below it.” 

A homeowner seeking to remove trees below the required minimum must file a planting plan as part of the permit process. The plan must show how the property returns to the required tree count. Commercial properties have 15 years to meet coverage standards, but residential properties must do so at the time of the permit. 

Deputy Mayor Malcolm Miller linked the issue to the age of many local neighborhoods. Subdivisions developed in the 1960s often have big, tall trees on small and medium-sized lots, he said. He added the council has revisited its tree protection rules more than once in recent years. 

“Over the years, obviously those trees are going to pose a danger to either the property itself or an adjacent property,” Miller said. “So in a lot of cases, you’ll find people needing to take trees down, but also having to look at a city code that doesn’t quite work well with their needs.” 

Enforcement, opposition 

Shepherd told the council he believed three enforcement cases have stalled because current rules give staff few options to resolve them. The amendments reclassify general tree code violations from misdemeanors to civil violations, handled through Chapter 14.40 of the municipal code. 

Violators must still replant affected sites and may be required to pay for the value of lost vegetation. Any payment above restoration costs goes into a city tree account for planting in other parts of Lacey, and a hearing examiner can reduce the amount in limited cases or double it for repeat offenders. 

A third amendment adds a 5,000-board-foot timber threshold to the city definition of a Class IV forest practice activity. The previous definition omitted that standard from Washington Administrative Code Title 222. Planning staff requested the change to match state regulations and give permit applicants more clarity. 

The proposals prompted a split response at a planning commission public hearing on Aug. 26. Some participants sought more freedom to remove trees not classified as hazardous by the City of Lacey Arborist. Others emphasized the benefits of mature trees, including carbon absorption, stormwater management, urban cooling and wildlife habitat. 

The commission favored further review and additional community participation through the upcoming Urban Forest Management Plan update. One commissioner abstained from the recommendation. 

The city council weighed that recommendation, public testimony and staff alternatives at an Oct. 13 work session. Council members then directed staff to prepare a narrower ordinance and left the remaining tree topics on the city's docket for the plan update in 2027. 

Comments

1 comment on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here

  • ClimateTeam

    Dumb! Trees help mitigate climate change plus provide beauty, cleaner air, and cooler temps. Lacey is going backwards.

    Report this